Podcast (therapist-confidential): Play in new window | Download
Travis Heath
Clinical Psychologist, Educator, Author and Head of Content, Psychotherapy.net
Travis Heath, PhD, is a licensed psychologist and has been in community practice for nearly two decades. His scholarship has included looking at shifting from a multicultural approach to counseling to one of cultural democracy that invites people to heal in mediums that are culturally near. Other writings have focused on the use of rap music in narrative therapy, working with persons entangled in the criminal injustice system in ways that maintain their dignity, narrative practice stories as pedagogy, and a co-created questioning practice called reunion questions. He is co-author, with David Epston and Tom Carlson, of the first book on Contemporary Narrative Therapy released in June 2022 entitled, Reimagining Narrative Therapy Through Practice Stories and Autoethnography. He has presented his work in 10 countries to date.
Transcript
Announcement
Welcome to Therapist Confidential, a psychotherapy dot net podcast. And now here’s your host, Travis Heath.
Travis Heath
Hello everyone. Welcome back to the Therapist Confidential podcast. I’m your host, Travis Heath. And today we’re going to talk a little bit about closure. I don’t know if you hear this a lot. Those of you that are therapists, I imagine you might people coming to your door asking about closure or wanting closure or needing closure or thinking they’re supposed to have closure. And even if you’re not a therapist and you’re listening to this, I mean, I think that idea is out in the public discourse quite a bit.
This idea of closure. We need closure. We have to find closure. Maybe we’re in the process of getting closure. But something that’s interesting to me about this is what exactly is it? what is closure when we say that? And I’ve asked people this before, when they come in saying they want closure, like is closure having an understanding of Of something. Is it forgiveness? I guess that depends on the situation. Is it an apology? Is it no longer feeling hurt? Is it, meaning that they’ve moved all the way through grief, whatever that means.
But it’s interesting because it feels to me increasingly that there’s been this expectation created, that painful experiences should eventually reach some kind of emotional resolution. And I just start wondering, like, is that always true now? Now, certainly, like if we think about grief, people move through grief. I’m not sure they move through in the Kubler-Ross fashion, as some of us have been taught, but in different ways, people navigate and move through grief. But do they get closure? I mean, that word has such finality to it.
And it just it makes me wonder why it seems like we’re starting to assume that every difficult experience needs some sort of satisfying and final ending. I got an example that I’ve seen even in the last couple of weeks, right, is you have someone who comes to therapy and a partner has ended a relationship. In this case, abruptly ending a relationship. And then, the partner that comes to see me wants closure. And it makes me wonder, what is that? So maybe there’s an explanation that exists that would make the breakup less painful.
Maybe. Also, what if that explanation is unsatisfying? the explanation could just be, well, the other person changed their mind or they fell out of love. Or there’s a long history of X, Y, or Z. and often when people come in, they already have some sense of what it was. So I’ve actually found that looking for insight around that often doesn’t do a whole lot. But I wonder how much they’re up against this expectation that they have to find closure. And if they haven’t found closure, well, then they haven’t adequately processed.
And oh, there’s another word processed, whatever they’re supposed to process about this. Now, I’m not saying that after something like a breakup in this example, that it’s not helpful to talk about that and talk through emotions, or maybe notice emotions that may be visiting us that are unpleasant or that we try to avoid. I mean, I think there can be value in that, but does all of that lead to closure? I’m not so certain it does. And this is an uncomfortable question, but as I was preparing for this episode today, it’s one that I returned to a lot, which is that what if some things never get resolved?
What if some bits of grief or difficult experiences that we have, we carry with us to a degree for our entire lives? Now, of course, I raise that. And that’s unpleasant to think about. I mean, who who among us wants to carry that with us? But I just wonder if, you know, do we actually get closure or are some things, some tragedies, experiences of grief, etc.? Are they just things to live with and we learn how to live alongside them. I do wonder if this understanding that, you know, when we get insight about something or a deeper level of processing and understanding about something, that that brings peace, I wonder about that.
Like, I wonder if it’s a myth to some degree. As therapists, as a group, we tend to place enormous value on insight and understanding. But understanding why something happened doesn’t necessarily make it hurt any less, And in fact, sometimes I think explanations can create more questions rather than actually providing resolution. So in that way, the search for insider understanding can become like an endless pursuit. That, in a weird way, keeps us connected to the very thing we’re trying to move beyond.
I’ll try to give you an example of what I mean there. This is one that I’ve seen in a number of different ways over the years, but I’m thinking of a particular instance, relatively recent instance, when I was working with a person, an adult in therapy, and part of what they came to understand during our conversations was that their father was, and this is using their words. And these words, I think, are borrowed from the culture was emotionally unavailable. And so, okay, their dad was emotionally unavailable.
Now, what’s interesting is at least the way that I go about these sorts of conversations is I often try to ask questions to understand the broader context, right? The broader context means the context of their life, their familial life, but also the broader cultural contexts, because fathers have often been emotionally unavailable. Now, one way of looking at that is of course, saying, well, men are just not capable of being emotionally available. I don’t believe that, by the way. But the way that the culture stories, how men and fathers are supposed to show up.
It would be reasonable to believe that a lot of people adopt that as an absolute truth. That that, hey, that’s just part of the deal that men aren’t emotionally available. Now, this particular father had a number of, reasons why. I mean, his father wasn’t emotionally available. Right. There were a number of things that happened in his life. And so this client was able to develop a compassion for their father’s circumstances. Right. And a deeper understanding, contextualizing it, etc.. But none of that erased what they missed growing up.
So they really wanted to dive in to understanding all of this. And then they understood it. But it’s almost like they’re disappointed in the end because they’re like, yeah, but I still feel the same way. And in this way, then seeking a deeper understanding became another way of like feeling stuck or even remaining stuck. Now, that’s not to say there was no value in going through that. Actually, I think there could have been value in me asking questions about this, us developing a deeper contextual understanding of what was happening.
Us understanding how it was impacting the client I was working with and how the client was responding to it. And then ultimately where it led us was to this idea of how does the person live alongside this? Not how do they gain enough insight about it that now they have closure and it doesn’t bother them anymore? But if we don’t take that next step of, of like, hey, maybe this is something we’re just going to have to learn to live alongside, which is very painful.
Most people would rather not do that understandably. Right? But if we don’t take that other step, they could do, all of this quote unquote therapeutic work only to find out that they’re still stuck? And if we’re not careful, they start to feel like they’re the problem. They’re like, well, see, I got all this great therapy for weeks or months or years or whatever it was. And see, I’m still stuck. So even the best therapy doesn’t work on me. And then people start blaming themselves, which I wonder in this case, if that’s not really the case.
One of the culprits here is the idea that there should be closure, and somehow they’re not doing the right work to find it. I think another thing that’s tricky about this notion of closure is that sometimes the sort of piece that we’re searching for in quote unquote, closure may be dependent on other people. Like, what I mean is sometimes closure mandates that someone else apologizes or they acknowledge wrongdoing, or they provide some sort of satisfying explanation of their behavior. But what happens then when that person refuses to do so?
Or maybe they’re incapable of doing so. Or perhaps they’re no longer alive and can no longer do so. And so it’s this idea of justice and accountability, which it makes sense why that’s important to people in the world. But is there a way that we can still value justice and accountability in the world without making our emotional futures dependent on receiving it? And if what we’re wanting is closure and this is how we’re defining closure. And we can’t get those things.
Well, then it starts to become impossible. I’ve seen this happen in so many different ways. I’ve seen it happen in couples therapy and individual therapy, etc.. Family therapy, like a typical way is someone could wait years for an apology from a partner, a family member, whomever it is. And what’s interesting is that sometimes people can’t get it for the reasons we talked about, right? The other person refuses or is incapable, or they’re no longer alive. So sometimes they just can’t get it.
And the fact that they can, it’s sort of tortures them. But if the person is still alive, for example, and I’ve seen this happen, eventually they actually receive what they want. They actually receive, let’s say, the apology. But then they discover that they still feel angry so that the apology didn’t even do what they were hoping it would do. And so when we talk about closure and that closure requires something of other people. That’s tough because it makes me wonder then, are we setting people up in a certain way, not just us as therapists, but this culture that talks about closure, where we make the people who hurt us, the gatekeepers to our healing.
That seems really risky because as soon as that leaves our domain and goes to the domain of others, I mean, there’s no guarantee that that’s going to happen now. Of course, I want to say sometimes these things do happen, right? Sometimes people do apologize. Sometimes it does leave people feeling more satisfied. So I’m not saying that that never happens. What I’m critiquing here is the idea that every person has to have closure. And even if we get the apology, as I was mentioning a minute ago, that doesn’t necessarily mean we’ll have the quote unquote closure that we’re wanting.
And so again, what I’m critiquing is this notion that there has to be closure, something that’s so robust and final. And I do wonder if us therapists are part of the problem. I mean, therapy Often emphasizes processing, working through healing, moving through, and resolving painful experiences. Right. At least I think that’s often what therapy can involve. And again, I’m not saying there isn’t value in any of that, but I do wonder if these ideas can, even if unwittingly, suggest that lingering sadness or anger or regret represents unfinished psychological work, unfinished emotional work, unfinished therapeutic work, etc.
in other words, that if we have lingering sadness, anger, regret, grief, etc., it’s because we still have work we need to do around it. And I don’t know that that’s always true because, for example, we could lose a person that’s very close to us via death or just the end of a relationship, for example. And that may be something where intermittently sadness, anger, grief, etc. shows up for the rest of our life around that. And again, I understand that that is an unpleasant proposition.
And I wonder if it’s still sometimes true. And I also wonder, as therapists, maybe sometimes we push towards resolution because we’re uncomfortable with uncertainty, or we want evidence that therapy is working, or we want evidence that therapy can help give this thing closure to someone that the culture says they’re supposed to have. An example I can think of in my own work, again, I’ve seen this show up in various different ways. But, let’s say that a client has spent years exploring a difficult childhood, some in therapy, maybe in with different therapists over the years, over decades, even in their own work, their own sort of self exploratory work.
And overall, let’s say that they’re doing pretty well in life. They’re getting along pretty well in life. They enjoy life, they’re doing pretty well in their relationships, etc. as well as we can do in this world. But they still sometimes experience sadness or anger about their upbringing. Now, the question that can emerge, and it’s an interesting one from a therapeutic standpoint, is, well, if they still experience that sadness sometimes, or that anger, that grief, does that mean there’s more work to do?
And I think the answer to that question is complicated. I worry, though, if people think the answer, especially us as therapists, think the answer to that question is always yes. If there’s lingering sadness, grief, anger, whatever, these emotions that we’re supposed to resolve in some way, does that mean there’s more work to do? And I guess an answer that feels more comfortable to me is maybe, and perhaps it depends on the person and the set of circumstances, etc. but it makes me wonder, are we sometimes then trying to help people resolve experiences that can’t ultimately be resolved at a final level, or maybe in some cases don’t actually need to be resolved.
Part of what I think we’re wrestling with here is that maybe some things never make complete sense. And as beings and, you know, how much I’m into stories and narratives that exist and whether those be narratives we’re forming about ourselves or that the culture at large is forming about us. Maybe some things don’t always make sense. Maybe not every loss has with it some sort of lesson that we take away. That doesn’t mean that there are never lessons that come along from loss, but maybe not every loss has that lesson.
Maybe not every hurt or betrayal has some sort of satisfying bit of insight or explanation. And this one oof, this really moves against some dominant ideas in the culture. But maybe not every painful experience makes us stronger. I know that’s heresy to say that out loud, but I wonder. Certainly painful experiences can help make us stronger sometimes, or help make some people in some circumstances stronger. But I wonder about is it that’s a lot of pressure in that actually, because if you tell me that every painful experience has to make me stronger, what happens when some of the painful experiences I have don’t.
Well, then I end up feeling like I’m doing something wrong or there’s something wrong, with me. Maybe something that can’t be fixed. That’s deeply wrong with me. Our culture seems to encourage us to turn our suffering into meaning. And certainly suffering sometimes does help produce meaning. But what happens then when meaning making becomes just another obligation of the culture? It’s like something that’s supposed to happen with this. And then also there’s this promise that, well, once we turn our suffering into meaning, then we find closure.
And I do wonder if maybe Sometimes the task here involves us learning to live with that uncertainty rather than eliminating it. Learning to live with that grief that may intermittently visit us around a particular topic or memory, rather than just eliminating it all together. Maybe every difficult experience doesn’t make us stronger. Maybe we don’t always have to find the silver lining. Maybe sometimes we just recognize that something harmful or very emotionally difficult happened. Why do we feel compelled to make something meaningful out of everything that’s painful?
And again, to me, what I just said, why do we feel compelled? It’s not that it’s bad if we find meaning in something painful or difficult. I actually think those can be really important stories for people. But what I’m questioning here is the feeling compelled part. I think that can create pressure to make people feel like, oh gosh, I haven’t resolved this yet because I haven’t found this great meaning that’s come from it. And I wonder if sometimes that does more harm than good.
And so then we can shift a little bit in how we approach that, right? Instead of asking what meaning people have found, we can approach more tentatively, is this something in which there’s some meaning emerging? Where have you come to understand that there should be meaning emerging from this? Right. And that if there isn’t meaning that’s emerging, I wonder if that’s okay. And if there is, I wonder if that’s okay too. And we could be curious about whatever the outcome might be around this.
Rather than taking this mandate from the culture that we have to find meaning in all of our pain. And by the way, not just that we find meaning, but it’s supposed to be like profound meaning. It’s supposed to be like meaning that changes our life. I wonder if that creates a lot of pressure for people. And I wonder what the consequences of that might be. And then that makes me wonder about Moving forward without moving on, which is not closure, right?
Because closure implies that we move on. But I wonder what happens when we continue to move forward and we don’t always move on. Some experiences might remain painful throughout our lives. Now, that doesn’t mean that they’re acutely painful all the time, It just means that that pain may pop up at various times for various different reasons. But if we’re able to accept that some experiences might be intermittently painful throughout our lives, what if then we don’t immediately jump to that meaning that we’re stuck, or that we have to work through something?
there’s a difference between something continuing to matter to us and, something continuing to completely dominate our lives, right? Like if I’ve lost a person that was very important to me, maybe I want them to continue to matter. Now, that doesn’t mean that the loss of that person, whether that be from death or just the end of a relationship, means that it has to dominate my life henceforth. But maybe the fact that I sometimes feel sadness, grief, pain, anger, whatever it is around, the loss of that person just means that that person continues to matter to me.
It doesn’t, though, mean it has to dominate my whole existence now for a time. It often does, doesn’t it? Because after a loss, I mean, usually for most of us, that’s very overwhelming and it may dominate our existence or most of it for a period of time. But the fact that I feel something about that as the years go on, maybe that just means that person matters to me and not that I failed to find closure. And then. And those of you that have heard me speak about this before, this is probably nothing new.
It’s a big part of how I think about this kind of work. But maybe healing then isn’t about eliminating pain, but it’s about changing our relationship with that pain. Like I can think of someone I worked with who lost their spouse, I don’t know, it was probably twenty years ago at this point. And they wonder about, well, sometimes I cry when I have memories of this spouse. And they’re like, well, I think I have a fulfilling life. You know, I don’t think I have a bad life, but gosh, that grief still shows up.
And then they start questioning themselves and saying, gosh, why can’t I find closure? Which is always an interesting question to me because and I don’t say it exactly this way to the person I’m speaking quickly here on a podcast, but I’m curious and I ask questions about it. But I wonder if this says more about the culture and the culture’s expectation than it does my client, that somehow the fact that they feel sadness and grief and it pops up sometimes, maybe that just shows that person matters to them, and maybe it doesn’t show that they have failed to achieve closure.
Maybe what this actually says is the culture’s mandate that we must find closure with anything is sometimes problematic for people. Like what if we can live meaningful lives without resolving and getting closure with everything that’s happened to us, that’s difficult. And that makes me wonder if perhaps closure isn’t something we always need to achieve. Maybe it’s one possible way of relating to painful experiences. So if somebody tells me, hey, I’ve achieved closure with this, I’m not trying to say that’s bad.
Although often I have had people come in and say, oh, I’ve already found closure with that. And lo and behold, no, they haven’t, because something pops up and the pain resurfaces. So if we could think of closure as one possibility, one possible way of relating to painful experiences, I’m okay with that. But I worry about it being held up as the gold standard that we’re all supposed to achieve. And I really when someone says they’ve had closure, I’m curious about that.
Not to say that people never find that, but I found that often when they say that they haven’t and it comes back in some way, and then that idea of changing our relationship over time to whatever it is that’s painful, What I mean is we can continue to feel grief, and that doesn’t mean it’s going to consume every waking moment, even though when it first happens, it often is. And that seems like something that is close to universal for human beings.
Now, whether they process this outwardly or they cry or they, you know, people hold that grief differently, but often it feels consuming in the initial stages. Right. But as we progress, and I don’t know if it’s as we progress, it’s just as time continues to move, maybe we can continue to feel grief and it doesn’t consume us, but we also don’t have to find closure to it. Maybe we can carry unanswered questions without spending all of our lives trying to find all the answers to those questions.
And maybe there are some that we do need to try to find answers to. And just going through that process is important, but maybe we can be discerning about this with each question, with each person, and maybe we can acknowledge that something still hurts without immediately interpreting that pain as evidence that something is wrong or that we have to do more processing. And so in that way, maybe the question isn’t whether we’ve found closure, but whether our pursuit of that closure is helping us live the lives we want to live.
Maybe for some people, the pursuit of closure is important, and it’s not actually about whether they find it or not. But if it’s about an outcome of actually getting closure, I worry about what happens if we’re in constant pursuit of it. And this is the hard part. And it’s hard. It’s hard for me in my own life as I consider it, right? It’s not just the people we work with. Maybe some experiences never make complete sense. Maybe some questions or worries we have never get answered.
Maybe some of the pains we carry never completely disappear. But none of that necessarily means we’re stuck, or that we haven’t healed enough, or that there’s something left for us to figure out. And that’s where I think therapy gets interesting is that, yes, we find ourselves in this place where it’s like, okay, is it worth continuing to pursue some of this? Can we be curious about whether you’re actually stuck or not or haven’t healed with regard to something or not? And then with each person, maybe we start to discover, is this something worth continuing to pursue?
Or is it not? But what’s making the decision for us isn’t the cultural mandate that they must find closure, but rather trying to get in touch with what the person is actually feeling or wanting, and maybe how with how the person is already responding to things. So sometimes I think what I’m starting to figure out anyways is that sometimes life continues without resolution. And that’s difficult and painful in its own right. But maybe sometimes the work in therapy isn’t trying to force closure resolution, but rather helping people begin to live alongside the idea that sometimes we won’t find it.
We won’t find resolution, but that life continues alongside it. All right, everyone, thanks for hanging out with me today on this solo episode. I really appreciate y’all listening. If you’re enjoying the podcast, please give us ratings and reviews and all the things that will hopefully help us keep this podcast going. If you found this interesting or if it makes you think of someone in your life, a colleague, a friend, a family member, please send it to them and perhaps they can give it a listen to. All right everyone, until next time.